The Readventurer
  • Home
  • YA Reviews
  • Adult Reviews
  • Contests and Giveaways
  • Policies
  • About Us
    • Flannery's Challenges
    • Catie's Challenges
  • Contact Us

YA Review: Holier Than Thou by Laura Buzo

6/5/2012

11 Comments

 
We're doing something a little bit different for this review today.  And admittedly, it's quite long.  Last week we all read this book at the same time. We planned to collaborate on one review, but then we all ended up having completely different reactions! The discussion threads were long and wordy and even though we had different points of view, we loved discussing this book. So we thought we'd give all of you the opportunity to read three perspectives on this new release from Laura Buzo.  Flannery brought some amazing and creative pictures, Tatiana brought her always-spot-on critical eye, and Catie brought a few tunes.  Let the three-way commence!
Holier Than Thou Laura Buzo cover
Holier Than Thou
Author: Laura Buzo
Publication Date: 5/1/12
Publisher: Allen & Unwin

[Goodreads | Fishpond]

Blurb(GR):
 
Holly Yarkov has a boyfriend who is a gift from the universe. She has a job that fulfills her even as it wears her down. She has a core group of friends from high school. And she has a layer of steel around her heart that is beginning to tarnish. Just as she is reaching for a future she can't quite see, Holly is borne back into the past by memories of her beloved father, and of the boy-who-might-have-been...

Grief and longing run like veins of quicksilver through this beautiful novel, at once gloriously funny and achingly sad.

Laura's confident, astute and witty voice has already been recognised with the success of Good Oil, with North American English rights sold to Knopf and German language rights sold to Arena. It was also shortlisted for the Prime Minister's Literary Awards. Her second novel is extraordinary and bittersweet – and shows us exactly what it is like to be a young person today – navigating the complexities of work, love, family and how to pay the rent.

Readventurer F Signature
For the record, I'd just like to say that I chuckle every time we talk about doing a three-way...review. Sure, it's immature, but I never said I was mature, did I?  Take this art project, for example:
Picture
Picture
I spent a huge amount of time in high school and occasionally in college playing The Sims. My younger sister and I have discussions about where are Sims meters are at any given time and it makes total sense to us. In the chart on the left, you can see where I'd like my meters to be at any given time. If you approach me when my meters are at those levels, I will be chipper like no one's business. In Holier Than Thou, Holly's meters are, well, a total crapfest. She's in a draining job where she receives little recognition for the work she does, she and her live-in boyfriend don't talk about anything, and she's lost touch with all of her friends. The only thing Holly looks forward to is spending time with her co-worker Nick, who trains in circus acts during his free time. The two of them develop a smooth friendship where they can toss movie quotes back and forth and she maintains a relationship with him and talks to him about all the things she isn't talking to her boyfriend about. 
Picture
I think a lot of my connection to Holly had to do with her relationship with her friends. I love my friends to death, all of them, so when I spent two years doing service work, mostly gutting and rebuilding after Katrina, and then I'd go visit friends and they'd say things like, "Oh, is that stuff still going on down there?" and "I thought everything was better now," it would make my blood absolutely boil. At the same time, everyone is doing their own thing so I'm sure they probably wanted to tell me about their jobs and I'd like to think that I didn't trivialize their experiences. But I'm sure I probably did, so I could totally identify with Holly's holier-than-thou persona. It's hard to take it down a notch to socialize when you have a huge emotional attachment to your job.

This is one of those books that readers will either totally connect to or not so much, as totally evidenced by the reviews on Goodreads (and in this three-way! heh), and it is understandable. There isn't a ton of plot movement, but I thought the book flew by because I was enthralled with the characters, what choices they would make, and whether Holly's Sims meters would get the upturn that I kept hoping they would. Holly compartmentalized grief from the death of her father, she's mourning the loss of several friendships, and she's wondering about her relationship. This book is just about the buildup, buildup, buildup, and release. I love it all the more for the fact that many questions are never answered. That's life. 

5/5 stars

Readventurer T Signature
If I am being honest, the most fun I had while reading Holier Than Thou was when I was contemplating if this new emerging genre of "New Adult" fiction would be for me. If you are not familiar with the idea of "New Adult" (as opposed to "Young Adult" or "Adult")  fiction, this term seems to have been coined by the St. Martin's Press' publishing team back in 2009 when they announced a writing contest seeking fiction similar to YA that can be published and marketed as adult - a sort of an “older YA” or “new adult” with protagonists 18 or older, but 20s are preferred. Editing assistant at St. Martin's Press S. Jae-Jones clarified that "New Adult is about young adulthood, when you are an adult but have not established your life as one (career, family, what-have-you)." And Sarah LaPolla clarifies it even further, saying that such books would be about "the college experience, figuring out grad school, jobs, not living off your parents, etc."

I don't know if St. Martin's actually found and published any projects following this contest, but "New Adult" term appears to have stuck. There have been a few titles that could be categorized as "New Adult" that I adored - Melina Marchetta's The Piper's Son, Gayle Forman's Where She Went and Buzo's own Good Oil. I can't say I felt the same way about Holier Than Thou, which is positively a "New Adult" title.

23-year old Holly is fresh out of college, with a new job, a new serious boyfriend and a new very own apartment. She is happy and liberated, that is until she isn't anymore. The job is exhausting psychologically, the boyfriend is not as shiny any more and old school friends are distant and busy. Suddenly this adulthood seems too difficult to Holly...

In spite of my high hopes (after all, Good Oil was one of my top favorite books of last year), reading Holier Than Thou wasn't a riveting or even pleasant experience for me.

For one, my general attitude towards "New Adult" set of issues is pretty dismissive. Sarah LaPolla put a great name to what bothers me the most about "New Adult" lit - it is its emphasis on and exploration of "extended adolescence." Funny that watching HBO's new show Girls was what cemented my thoughts on "New Adult" themes - "New Adult" experiences, to me, are more often than not colored by pretentiousness, immaturity, self-entitlement and moochery. I am not quite sure why I am so negative towards these issues, being barely out of "New Adult" years myself. Maybe because my own "New Adult" experience was never as depressing as Holly's seems to be. I finished school, I didn't have neither opportunity nor desire to live off my parents' monetary support any longer, I started my adult life in a different country, with a different set of acquaintances and a new culture, and it was exciting, difficult too, with crappy jobs and financial strain, but it was exciting most of all. It is not interesting or compelling to me to observe people who make big deals out of issues that are not crucial, like Holly. If you don't like your job - get another one, if you are attracted to a man other than the one you are committed to - sit for a minute and examine which relationship you want to pursue, if your former friends are now distant and have new interests - that's just natural, people grow up and grow apart. None of Holly's experiences struck me as life-altering or worthy of the amount of ennui presented in this novel.

But mainly I think I just didn't connect with Holly and her friends on a personal level. With vibrant characters I can get into pretty much any story, but as told in Holly's words, it was pretty dull, colorless, sad and uninteresting to me. Holier Than Thou reminded me of a few pretentious books about college students - Jeffrey Eugenides' The Marriage Plot or Donna Tartt's The Secret History which center on students obsessed with finding meaning of life, but not finding it most likely because of the life of privilege they've led, and a couple of sad, full of adult angst novels like Anna Quindlen's One True Thing or Jennifer Weiner's In Her Shoes. Essentially, Holier Than Thou turned out to be for me nothing more than another piece of depressing women's fiction, made even more unsatisfying by the completely open, ambiguous ending. Maybe I simply don't have that college years' nostalgia that would have helped me connect with Holly's issues? Or maybe I didn't have the luxury of time to lament, at length, my disappearing careless (did I have it?) youth and the decline of parting and loss of friends? Either way, Holier Than Thou made very little impact on me.

2.5/5 stars
Readventurer C Signature
It’s only rarely that I’ve encountered a writer like this, who so skillfully encourages the reader to participate. Laura Buzo’s writing in this book may appear simple and straightforward, but it’s deceptively so. Not only does she seamlessly weave together three different timelines, she achieves the perfect balance between what is stated and what isn’t. She gives us just enough. Instead of spelling out exactly how Holly feels, she leads us directly to our own emotions and memories. As a result, this book will be a very personal experience for a lot of readers. I know that it was for me.  And the most impressive thing is that even as she’s pulling off these rather complicated feats in the background, she’s achieving a heartbreakingly simple and straightforward tone for Holly in the foreground. Holly, who will joke and seem almost bland as she tells us about her father’s slow death, or the boy she loved but never got to have, or how her friends are slowly slipping away, or how she constantly wonders about what might have been. She’s been labeled a survivor, a success, a do-gooder. She has a rigid set of rules that she feels accountable to all the time, but which are completely unrealistic. She’s a woman of steel.  As a card-carrying member of that tribe, I can utterly relate to how hollow that label really is. In fact I related to this book in so many ways; the prospect of discussing them all is overwhelming. This book just fits right inside my skin.
This book made me remember:

Having my own place for the first time: it was tiny and dingy but it was mine. Quoting The Simpsons to anyone and everyone. Listening to hours of Tori Amos. How I used to feel about having kids. All the friends that flowed into and out of my life.  How impossible it was hold on to any of them, no matter how much I might have wanted to. That one person who I’ll never be able to forget, even though I probably should. Working in public service: facing the gruesome side of humanity every day and finding not always appropriate ways to cope with that. Watching my friends work in the private sector. Believing I could make a difference. Realizing that I probably never would. Breaking rules I thought were set in stone. Meeting the one, several times. Never knowing for sure if I made the right decision about anything. Regretting. 

This is one case where I actually feel like I got much much more out of this book because I read it as an older adult.  I can look back at my early twenties now and realize that losing friends happens all the time, to everyone (and really, it never stops sucking). I can see how pointless it was to second guess decisions that could never be re-made.  I can see that I’m a public servant through and through and it was fulfilling to me, even if I didn’t make a difference. I can see that all of those rules that I held so dear were really just holding me back. And I can see that the real steel isn’t earned by holding it together indefinitely. The real steel is earned by falling apart and then putting yourself back together again.

Reading this as an older adult had another effect on me too – it made the ending about one hundred times more devastating, because I could feel everything that was ahead for Holly. I love ambiguous endings - so much so that a few of my friends refer to them as “Catie endings.” This ending is without a doubt a Catie ending. Holy moly but did she give it right to me. With a side of chips. She gives us Holly’s deceptively strong outer walls, her rapidly rising tide of grief and regret, and just as the first cracks are starting to show, just as we get a glimpse of how deep that pool goes; it’s over. This is a beautiful, poignant, devastating snapshot of the early twenties experience and it is one of my favorite reads of the year.

Perfect Musical Pairing
The Jezabels - Easy To Love
(Random aside the first: I want her hair so badly. Random aside the second: their drummer is SO TALENTED.) My friend Reynje made an amazing playlist for this book, which is how I got introduced to The Jezabels. I could have picked so many of their songs (and indeed, their latest albums have become like my soundtrack for this book), but I chose this one because I’m pretty sure it’s just longing distilled. This song all about running into that person you can’t have and trying to do anything not to regret, even though you can’t stop. When the lead singer says “please, just let me be easy to love” and I think about Holly it just about guts me.

4.5/5 Stars


Holier Than Thou is only $12.06 with free shipping from Fishpond. Do it! You know you want to.
11 Comments
Anna link
6/4/2012 11:55:59 pm

Wow. Very interesting perspectives. I suspect I may like this one A LOT, but I completely get what Tatiana is saying. Looking back, this was a period of my life when I never felt constrained (not that I do now!) so it will be interesting to read it withthis in mind.
Great review(s)! X

Reply
Catie (The Readventurer) link
6/5/2012 05:43:14 am

Thanks Anna! Even though I loved this book, I was nodding right along with her review too. I've definitely felt that same way about books before. It just didn't happen with this particular one! But I really enjoyed seeing how differently we all reacted. Hope you give this one a try!

Reply
Maggie, Young Adult Anonymous link
6/5/2012 01:14:02 am

Random: Your three-way talk reminds me of The Real World: New Orleans when a drunk Melissa says, "You, me, and Jamie should have a menagerie."

Flannerier than thou: Your pics! I think you're who I think I am in my head when in reality I'm the one asking vapid questions.

Tatiana: My reaction to Good Oil was so ambivalent I actually tried to change my pre-order of this book to something else. It's interesting reading your take on this. And I had no idea that's how the New Adult term was coined.

Catie: Catie ending! And you could TOTALLY rock that hair!

Reply
Catie (The Readventurer) link
6/5/2012 05:48:42 am

It always makes me think of that scene in Scrubs - "now was it two girls and a guy, or a devil's threesome? All girl." And then I chuckle immaturely because we're...all...girls. Yeah. Anyway.

Catie ending times a million! :) When my oldest daughter saw that video she said "that girl looks like you" and it was the best thing anyone's ever said to me (may or may not be a slight exaggeration).

Reply
VeganYANerds link
6/5/2012 08:33:56 am

+ 1000000 bonus points for the Scrubs quote ;)

Maja link
6/5/2012 04:07:22 am

I wish you ladies would do this more often! It was interesting when Tatiana and Catie reviewed The Drowned Cities because, even though they both loved it, they experienced it differently. But this, three completely different reviews, one after the other, is amazing.

Catie, really, if this is what happens after a reviewer's block, you should have them more often. You just keep surprising me.

Reply
Catie (The Readventurer) link
6/5/2012 05:58:53 am

I think it's a great idea too! Plus it's always fun to read a book with these two. Maja, you have no idea how long it took me to write that damn thing. For some reason the books I love are always the hardest, know what I mean? I'm glad you liked it though - thanks :)

Reply
Jasprit link
6/5/2012 05:47:52 am

I love this idea of a three way review! Especially as all your thoughts and feelings about this book were fundamentally so different! Sorry this book didn't work out for you as you'd hoped Tatiana! All of your reviews rock ladies!

Reply
Catie (The Readventurer) link
6/5/2012 06:02:37 am

Thanks Jasprit! We didn't expect that to happen but it was really neat that it did - I think it made this post so much more interesting.

Reply
VeganYANerds link
6/5/2012 08:38:39 am

Woh, Tatiana your review broke my heart a little bit, it's only the second negative review I've read of HTT and I hope it's the last! But not everyone has a similar life to Holly so it makes sense that some people just won't get this book.

Flann - good on your for doing your volunteer work, that is just fantastic. I think a lot of people forget that work continues long after the disaster is over, it's the same with the floods we had here. I guess that's how I feel about my vegan/animal welfare stuff. I have friends who act sympathetically and say they they agree and oh how terrible it is but the next minute they're tucking into a steak and talking about how they bought a leather jacket on sale, FFS! :/

Catie - book yourself in and get your hair styled, hun! You'd look well nice! And I love how close you felt to this book, I think you must have connected with this so strongly and I totally agree that I think it's much better to have read this as adult, I almost want to tell teens not to bother because they're not going to get it.

Reply
Chachic link
6/5/2012 04:04:33 pm

Lovely reviews, ladies! I love that all three of you posted your thoughts about this book. Sorry to hear that Tatiana didn't love this but I have a feeling I'd feel something similar to what Flann and Catie felt. I've very interested in New Adult novels and I feel like we don't have enough books focusing on the adjustments faced by people in their twenties. This post has made me more excited to read Holier Than Thou, I really should bump it up the TBR pile.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Follow Us On:

    Facebook Twitter Feed

    Subscribe:

    Subscribe
    Follow on Bloglovin

    Subscribe via email:

    Delivered by FeedBurner


    What We're Reading:

    Blood of my Blood cover

    Flannery

    Goodreads
    Monstrous Affections cover

     Tatiana

    Goodreads
    Rules of Civility cover

      Catie

    Goodreads

    Archives 

    March 2014
    September 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    August 2011
    July 2011
    June 2011

    Categories

    All
    Author Spotlight
    Book Events
    Book Vs. Movie
    Catie's Adult Reviews
    Catie's Y.A. Reviews
    Contest Or Giveaway
    Flannery's Adult Reviews
    Flannery's Y.A. Reviews
    If You Like This Maybe That
    Library Quest
    Odds & Ends On The Web
    Randomness
    Readalong Recaps
    She Made Me Do It
    Tatiana's Adult Reviews
    Tatiana's Y.A. Reviews
    Three Heads Are Better Than One Or Two
    Year Of The Classics


    Blogs We Follow

    Angieville
    Anna Scott Jots
    Badass Book Reviews
    The Book Geek
    The Book Smugglers
    Book Harbinger
    Books Take You Places
    Bunbury in the Stacks
    Chachic's Book Nook
    Clear Eyes, Full Shelves
    Collections
    Cuddlebuggery
    For the Love of Words
    The Galavanting Girl Books
    Inkcrush
    Intergalactic Academy
    Ivy Book Bindings
    The Nocturnal Library
    Rainy Day Ramblings
    The Readers Den
    The Reading Date
    Realm of Fiction
    Sash and Em
    Stacked
    The Unread Reader
    Vegan YA Nerds
    Wear The Old Coat
    Wordchasing
    Wrapped Up In Books
    Young Adult Anonymous 

    Grab A Button

    The Readventurer
    <div align="center"><a href="http://www.thereadventurer.com" title="The Readventurer"><img src="http://www.weebly.com/uploads/7/8/9/9/7899923/custom_themes/149267861480723643/files/TheReadventurer.png?1321429794244" alt="The Readventurer" style="border:none;" /></a></div>

    Parajunkee Design
    SiteLock
    Since 2/4/2012

Creative Commons LicenseThis work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 United States License.
Photos used under Creative Commons from savillent, vue3d, vue3d, ljcybergal